Published

Property Manager's Insurance Guide

Every managed block has people moving through it: residents, visitors, cleaners, contractors and, in many cases, directly employed staff. When any of them is hurt, or their property is damaged, two covers decide who pays: Employers' Liability and Public Liability. Get them wrong and the cost can land on the freeholder, the residents' company or the managing agent personally.

This guide explains how the two covers differ, who is legally required to hold what, where contractors create hidden exposure, and what a managing agent needs to be able to show when a slip or trip claim arrives. If you manage blocks on behalf of others, it is worth ten minutes of your time.

Public Liability men with building blocks as if assessing

Insurance under one roof

We are specialists in many types of insurance

Employers’ Liability and Public Liability: Two Covers, Two Different Jobs

Property managers often treat Employers’ Liability (EL) and Public Liability (PL) as a single line on a schedule. They are not. They respond to different people, rest on different legal footings, and fail in different ways. Knowing which one is meant to answer a given claim is the first step to making sure it can.

Employers’ Liability protects people who work for you. It responds when an employee is injured or made ill because of their work. Public Liability protects everyone else: residents, visitors, delivery drivers and passers-by who suffer injury or property damage because of the way a building or its management operates.

Question Employers’ Liability Public Liability
Who is protected? Employees, including some unpaid helpers and casual workers Third parties: residents, visitors, contractors’ visitors, the public
Is it a legal requirement? ✓ Yes, under the Employers’ Liability (Compulsory Insurance) Act 1969 ! Not by statute, but expected by leases, contracts and insurers
Minimum limit £5 million; many insurers offer £10 million No legal minimum; £5 million is the usual contractual standard
Typical block scenario A directly employed caretaker is injured on a ladder in the plant room A visitor trips on a loose paving slab outside the main entrance
Who enforces it? The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) The courts, through civil claims

£5m
minimum legal limit of indemnity for Employers’ Liability cover
£2,500
maximum fine for each day an employer operates without adequate EL insurance
5%
of employers required to hold EL cover had none, in an HSE survey from 2012

Who Counts as an Employee in a Managed Block?

Many managing agents assume EL is irrelevant to them because the agency itself is not the employer of anyone on site. In practice the picture is more mixed. A residents’ management company may directly employ a caretaker, a concierge or a cleaner. A freeholder may employ a resident porter. And your own agency has staff who visit buildings every day.

The test is the nature of the relationship and the degree of control, not what the paperwork is called. A contract of employment does not need to be written down, and it can be implied. Many people wrongly assume that because someone is self-employed and pays their own tax, EL does not apply. That assumption is risky: where the relationship looks like employment in practice, the cover is required.

The legal consequences of getting this wrong are direct. An employer without adequate cover can be fined up to £2,500 for each day it is uninsured, and up to £1,000 for failing to display a valid certificate or to produce it for an HSE inspector. More importantly, an injured employee still has a claim. Without cover, that claim is met from the employer’s own funds.

Residential block of flats with communal entrance and shared outdoor areas
Communal entrances, paths, stairwells and plant rooms are where most third-party injury claims in managed blocks begin.

Communal Areas and Slip and Trip Claims

Slip and trip claims are the everyday face of Public Liability in a managed block. They happen in car parks, on stairs, in entrance halls after rain, on paths in winter and on uneven paving that nobody has reported. Individually they are rarely dramatic. Collectively they are a steady source of claims, and they test whether a managing agent can show it had a proper system in place.

Two pieces of law frame the duty. Under the Occupiers’ Liability Act 1957, an occupier owes a common duty of care to lawful visitors. An occupier is anyone with a sufficient degree of control over the premises, which in a block can include the freeholder, an RMC or RTM company, and a managing agent exercising day-to-day control. The Occupiers’ Liability Act 1984 extends a more limited duty to people who are not lawful visitors, including trespassers, covering death and personal injury but not damage to property.

Alongside this, the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999 require risk assessment wherever people work. The flats themselves are private dwellings, but the courts and the HSE treat communal areas differently. If a cleaner, gardener, managing agent or repair contractor enters them, a risk assessment of those areas is needed, and it should cover the roof, external areas and structure as well as the interior.

“When a slip or trip claim arrives, the question is rarely whether someone fell. It is whether you can show what you did to prevent it.”

Why records matter more than good intentions

That is why documentation matters. Dated inspection records, logged repairs, winter maintenance arrangements and a clear reporting route for residents are the evidence that turns an arguable claim into a defensible one. Without them, the same facts can look like neglect.

Four Liability Gaps That Catch Property Managers Out

1
Contractors

Appointing contractors without verifying their insurance

If a contractor causes injury or damage while working on your block without adequate insurance, the claimant will look for someone who can pay. That is often the freeholder, the RMC or the managing agent. Accepting a verbal assurance, or an out-of-date certificate, leaves a gap that falls on you.

In practice: Obtain a current certificate before work starts, check the limit of indemnity and expiry date, and diarise renewals. A certificate checked when the contractor was first appointed may be long out of date.

2
Limits

Accepting a contractor’s cover that is too low for the work

A contractor with £1 million of PL cover working on a multi-storey block leaves a shortfall if a serious incident occurs. Many property managers and building owners treat £5 million as the minimum for any contractor on site, and that has been regarded as sensible practice for many years.

In practice: Set a minimum PL limit in your contractor terms, typically £5 million, and require the same of any sub-contractors the contractor brings in.

3
Staff

Overlooking directly employed on-site staff

A caretaker or cleaner employed by an RMC is an employee. If the block policy or the RMC’s own cover does not include Employers’ Liability, the company is in breach of the 1969 Act and exposed to a personal injury claim it cannot insure.

In practice: List everyone who works in each block, establish who employs them, and confirm that an EL certificate is in place and displayed where employees can see it.

4
Evidence

No record of inspections, repairs or reports

Slip and trip claims are won and lost on evidence. A defect that was reported and never logged, or a path that was inspected but never recorded, is very difficult to defend. Insurers and claimant solicitors both start by asking what the system was.

In practice: Keep a dated log of communal area inspections, defects reported, repairs completed and winter weather actions. Make it routine, not a reaction to a claim.

Property management professionals reviewing contractor insurance documents
Checking a contractor’s insurance certificate before work begins is one of the cheapest risk controls available to a managing agent.

Where Liability Lands When Something Goes Wrong

When an injury occurs in a managed block, the claimant’s solicitor will usually write to everyone who might be an occupier or a duty holder. That can include the freeholder, the RMC or RTM company, the managing agent and any contractor working on the day. Each will look to its own insurer, and each insurer will look at who controlled the area and who was meant to maintain it.

Contractors matter because their insurance is often the first line of response. If a contractor’s work caused the injury and the contractor holds adequate PL cover, that insurer can respond. If they do not, or their limit is exhausted, the remaining parties are exposed. Many insurers will also pursue recovery against a negligent contractor to recoup their outlay, but only if the contractor is worth pursuing, which in practice means insured.

The managing agent’s own position also needs attention. A managing agent is not simply a messenger. Where it has taken on responsibility for inspections, contractor appointment or repairs, its own Public Liability and Professional Indemnity cover should reflect that scope. Do not assume that the buildings policy covers the agency’s own errors; it generally does not.

The short version

Employers’ Liability answers for injuries to people who work for you, and it is compulsory. Public Liability answers for injuries and damage to everyone else, and in a managed block it is effectively essential.

Contractors, directly employed staff and communal area maintenance are the three places where cover most often has a gap. Check all three at every renewal.

Employers’ and Public Liability Checklist for Property Managers

  • Map who works in each block — identify every directly employed caretaker, cleaner or porter and establish who their employer is.
  • Confirm EL certificates are in place — at least £5 million, current, and displayed where employees can see them.
  • Check Public Liability is embedded in the block policy — and review the limit of indemnity against the size and use of each building.
  • Verify every contractor’s insurance before work starts — view the certificate, not a verbal assurance, and record the expiry date.
  • Set a minimum contractor PL limit — typically £5 million — and require sub-contractors to hold equivalent cover.
  • Carry out and record communal area risk assessments — covering stairs, paths, car parks, plant rooms and roofs, and review them after any change.
  • Keep a dated inspection and repairs log — including defects reported by residents and winter weather arrangements.
  • Review your own cover — confirm that the agency’s PL and Professional Indemnity match the duties you have actually taken on.

Not sure your liability cover matches the way your blocks are run?

Property Insurance Centre works with property managers across the UK to place buildings and liability cover that fits how managed blocks really operate, including contractors, on-site staff and communal areas. Get in touch for a no-obligation review of your current arrangements.

Speak to a Specialist
Or call us on 0800 085 3761

Sources: Employers’ Liability (Compulsory Insurance) Act 1969; Occupiers’ Liability Act 1957; Occupiers’ Liability Act 1984; Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999; British Pest Control Association guidance on Employers’ Liability insurance (citing HSE enforcement and 2012 HSE survey); CLEAR Insurance Management, Blocks of Flats: Slips and Trips; Flat Living guidance on contractor selection for block managers. This guide is for information purposes only and does not constitute insurance or legal advice. Always consult a qualified adviser for your specific circumstances.

Residential Landlord

Commercial Property

Why choose the Property Insurance Centre

Independent advice by approachable staff online or by phone

Access to a wide range of insurers to source suitable insurance cover for your needs

Bespoke Insurance Schemes & Portfolio Policies available

We can tailor your policy to suit your exact needs to give you complete peace of mind

Competitive Premiums

Cover available for the buildings while the property is being converted, renovated or extended

Over 40 years experience working with the best insurers in the UK

Excellent communication so that you understand what risks you are insured against

Why choose the Property Insurance Centre

Independent broker with staff you can speak to by phone or online

Access to a wide range of insurers to source suitable insurance cover for your needs

Bespoke Insurance Schemes & Portfolio Policies available

We can tailor your policy to suit your exact needs to give you complete peace of mind

Competitive Premiums

Cover available for the buildings while the property is being converted, renovated or extended

Over 40 years experience working with the best insurers in the UK

Excellent communication so that you understand what risks you are insured against

Why choose the Property Insurance Centre

Independent broker with staff you can speak to by phone or online

Access to a wide range of insurers to source suitable insurance cover for your needs

Bespoke Insurance Schemes & Portfolio Policies available

We can tailor your policy to suit your exact needs to give you complete peace of mind

Competitive Premiums

Cover available for the buildings while the property is being converted, renovated or extended

Over 40 years experience working with the best insurers in the UK

Excellent communication so that you understand what risks you are insured against

Specialists in Commercial & Residential Insurance

We have over 40 years experience as Residential and Commercial Insurance Brokers. We find the right policy to suit your needs and understand the risks that a property owner can face in the course of ownership. We work closely with our Insurers to get the best rates and our experience and excellent relationships with them mean that we can provide cover for even the most difficult to place risks.

Whether you have an adverse claims history, a high value property or a large portfolio of properties, we can source suitable cover for you. Whatever your requirements, we can tailor a specialist property insurance policy to suit your exact needs and provide you with a range of quotes to choose from. Established in 1976, we are not a call centre but a specialist insurance broker with a traditional office mentality, where the client comes first.

Looking for a quote now? Give us a call on 0800 085 3761 or complete one of our quote request forms.

We are also authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority and you can view our registration here.

Get In Touch:

[contact-form-7 id="12585" title="New Callback"]

We accept most payment types including:

UK Call Handlers & Dedicated New Business Team

Call Us on 0800 085 3761

Kyle McCallum author Property Insurance Centre-
Website | + posts

New Business Supervisor and Cert CII Qualified – Approaching 10 years within the commercial insurance industry, Kyle is keen on ensuring that his clients are adequately insured with the cover they expect and require.

With his already vast knowledge and understanding of the insurance market, you can be confident your insurance needs will be met.

Kyle is qualified Level 3, Cert CII. Outside of insurance I am an avid Liverpool fan.